24 April 2012 | Express Yourself | Posted by
Foong Cheng Leong
Dissecting the presumption of fact relating
to publication in the controversial new Bill.
The Evidence (Amendment) (No. 2) Bill 2012
was one of the bills rushed and passed by the Parliament recently. Minister in
the Prime Minister’s Department, Datuk Seri Mohamed Nazri Aziz, when winding up
the Evidence (Amendment) Bill 2012, said the use of pseudonyms or anonymity by
any party to do cyber crimes had made it difficult for the action to be taken
against them. Hence, the Evidence Act 1950 must be amended to address the issue
of Internet anonymity.
The amendments introduced s. 114A into the
Evidence Act 1950 to provide for the presumption of fact in publication in
order to facilitate the identification and proving of the identity of an
anonymous person involved in publication through the internet. In simple words,
s. 114A introduces 3 circumstances where an Internet user is deemed to be a
publisher of a content unless proven otherwise by him or her.
Men in masks, beware of s.114A.
Although it is stated that the amendment is
to cover anonymous persons on the internet, the effect of the amendment is
quite wide. You see, we, especially social media network users, generally do
not use our real names on the Internet. We use nicknames and pseudonyms. Our
home addresses do not appear on our account. We sometimes use fictional
characters or even digitalized images of ourselves as our profile picture. All
these are done to protect our own privacy. So, if none of my personal details
appear on my account, does this mean I am anonymous? If someone’s identity
cannot be directly ascertained from his account, I would think that he would be
anonymous.
The new s. 114A(1) states that “A person
whose name, photograph or pseudonym appears on any publication depicting
himself as the owner, host , administrator, editor or sub-editor, or who in any
manner facilitates to publish or re-publish the publication is presumed to have
published or re-published the contents of the publication unless the contrary
is proved”. In simple words, if your name, photograph or pseudonym appears on
any publication depicting yourself as the aforesaid persons, you are deemed to
have published the content. So, for example, if someone creates a blog with
your name, you are deemed to have published the articles there unless you prove
otherwise. If you have a blog and someone posts a comment, you are deemed to
have published it. If you have a Facebook page and an user posts something on
your wall, you are deemed to have published it!
Subsection (2) provides a graver consequence.
If a posting originates from your account with a network service provider, you
are deemed to be the publisher unless the contrary is proved. In simple terms,
if a posting originates from your TM Unifi account, you are deemed to be the
publisher. In the following scenarios, you are deemed to be the publisher
unless you prove the contrary:-
(1) You have a home network with a few house
mates sharing one internet account. You are deemed to be the publisher even
though one of your house mates posts something offensive online.
(2) You have wireless network at home but you
did not secure your network. You are deemed to be the publisher even though
someone “piggybacks” your network to post something offensive.
(3) You have a party at home and allows your
friends to access your PC or wireless network. You are deemed to be the
publisher even though it was a friend who posted something offensive.
(4) Someone use your phone or tablet to post
something offensive. You are deemed to be the publisher.
As for subsection (3), you are presumed to
have published a content if you have custody or control of any computer which
the publication originates from. Here, you are deemed to be the publisher so
long your computer was the device that had posted the content. So if someone
“tweetjacks” you or naughtily updates your Facebook with something offensive,
you are deemed to be the publisher unless you prove otherwise.
Admittedly, the amendments certainly saves a
lot of the investigator’s time. It is very difficult to trace someone on the
Internet. It will make prosecution for, among others, defamation, offences
under the Communication and Multimedia Act 1998 and Computer Crimes Act 1997
and, election offences much easier. But it is not impossible to trace someone.
There are many cases where perpetrators are caught and charged.
I do not see the logic to deem someone to be
a publisher. If an investigator is unable to trace the anonymous internet user,
then why should the innocent Internet user take the rap? The onus of proof
should always be on the prosecuting side. In the English case of Applause
Store Productions Limited & Anor v Grant Raphael [2008] EWHC 1781 (QB),
the claimants were awarded £22,000 in damages against Raphael, an old school
friend, who had created a false personal profile of the claimants on Facebook.
The claimants convinced the Court that Raphael was the person who created the
fake profile even though he claimed that he had a party at his house and
someone in that party created the account.
In summary, the new amendments force an innocent
party to show that he is not the publisher. Victims of stolen identity or
hacking would have a lot more problems to fix. Since computers can be easily
manipulated and identity theft is quite rampant, it is dangerous to put the
onus on internet users. An internet user will need to give an alibi that it
wasn’t him. He needs to prove that he has no access to the computer at that
time of publication and he needs to produce call witnesses to support his
alibi.
Clearly, it is against our very fundamental
principal of “innocent until proven guilty”. With general election looming, I
fear this amendment will be used oppressively. Fortunately, the amendment is
not in force yet. I strongly hope that the government will relook into this
amendment.